Jeff - thanks for posting below information!
I just called paypal and talked to three different people - they told me that there was basically no chance in hell (well - they were slightly more polite about it) that they would re-open my case/the reinone case and give me ANY money back.
I paid directly out of my bank account back then... did you guys pay via CC? Paypal might have figured that they could avoid having you run a charge-back trough your CC by offering you half the money back out of THEIR pockets (I guess, they would be out the full amount if the CC company decided to run a full charge-back?!).
Just wondering. In my case, they were not very helpful at all and did not want to hear anything about other people, who are part of the same reinone-dispute, having gotten back at least half the money through them...
Hey, I'm happy some people here got some money back... would have been nice to at least get half the cash back... oh, well - paypal (in my case) sucks... or better, reinone that sucks...